On May 7, 2025, approximately 75 pro-Palestinian protesters were arrested at Columbia University’s Butler Library after occupying the reading room in a demonstration organized by Columbia University Apartheid Divest (CUAD). The university cited safety concerns and the presence of non-affiliated individuals as reasons for requesting NYPD intervention. Two campus safety officers were allegedly injured during the incident.

Many of those arrested were issued Desk Appearance Tickets (DATs), a common practice in New York for certain offenses. A DAT is a written notice issued by a police officer directing an individual to appear in criminal court at a future date in connection with an alleged offense. It allows the individual to remain out of custody until their court date.

Relevant Statutes and Potential Charges

The protesters may face charges such as trespassing (Penal Law §140.05 or §140.10), disorderly conduct (Penal Law §240.20), or criminal mischief (Penal Law §145.00) if property damage occurred. There could also be charges of Obstructing Governmental Administration (Penal Law §195.05) or Resisting Arrest (Penal Law 205.30) for those individuals accused of fighting with law enforcement officers during their arrests. These offenses are typically classified as violations or misdemeanors.

Possible Penalties

Convictions for these offenses can result in prison sentences and permanent criminal records (which may impact future employment and education). These arrests are also particularly problematic for foreign students on F-1 visas, as they could negatively impact immigration status in the current environment.

Failure to Appear Consequences

If an individual fails to appear in court on the date specified in the DAT, the court may issue a bench warrant for their arrest. Additionally, under Penal Law §215.58, willfully failing to appear within 30 days can result in a separate violation charge. In some cases, Mr. Galluzzo has been able to appear in court for his clients in lieu of their personal appearances.

Legal Considerations

Given the potential legal ramifications, individuals issued a DAT are advised to consult with a criminal defense attorney to understand their rights and options. Matthew Galluzzo is a former Manhattan prosecutor and experienced criminal defense attorney. He has represented many students arrested and accused of crimes relating to political protests, with an excellent track record of success. If you or a loved one have been arrested for the protests at Columbia University on May 7, you should strongly consider engaging Matthew Galluzzo.

News links:

Protesters arrested as Columbia calls in New York police to clear Gaza solidarity sit-in – as it happened

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators clash with security guards at Columbia University

Dozens of pro-Palestinian protesters arrested after Columbia calls in police