The National Trial Lawyers
Avvo Rating 10.0
Avvo Clients' Choice
Avvo Rating Superb
Expertise Badge
Avvo Clients' Choice

What is Assault in the Third Degree? The Basics (Part 2)

The Law Office of Matthew Galluzzo, PLLC Team

In this continuation from Part I of our discussion on assault, we discuss the sufficiency of allegations of physical injury.

So what constitutes substantial pain and what does not? The Court of Appeals has found sufficient evidence of substantial pain in the following instances:

  • Where victim was struck with a baseball bat resulting in discoloration, swelling and lost sensation to arm;
  • Where victim sustained a 1.5 inch laceration from a bullet which was redressed at the hospital and which was still oozing when treated;
  • Where lacerations to eye and hand resulted in “permanent spots” on hand and “terrible pain” after having been tripped, sat on, kicked and cut with knife;
  • Where victim lost consciousness, sustained contusions to neck, experienced pain, had difficulty swallowing and was prescribed medicine after being choked; and
  • Where suffered pain and symptoms for three to five weeks from a concussion and laceration to head, bruises and sprains, and a bruised and swollen foot.

It is important to note that in each case where substantial pain was found to exist, the Court pointed to some objective evidence to support the finding.

Conversely, the Court of Appeals has ruled that the following allegations set forth were insufficient to establish substantial pain:

  • Where incidental reference to a black eye without any development of its appearance, seriousness, accompanying swelling or suggestion of pain was made;
  • Where victim cried, felt an unspecified degree of pain and sustained a red mark after being hit twice by defendant;
  • Where victim suffered a one centimeter cut above her lip; and
  • Where the victim experienced swelling and redness which persisted for a week, without a specified level of pain.

While the determination of the existence of “substantial pain” is generally one for a jury, the prosecution is not entitled to simply plead the existence of “substantial pain” in a conclusory manner in order to escape sufficiency scrutiny. In other words, the injury must stand up to some form of objective scrutiny. For this reason, it is important for the attorney of a defendant charged with assault to review the charging document for sufficiency, and prepare a detailed motion to dismiss or reduce the charges where appropriate. Most of the cases we handle involve allegations which fall somewhere in between the two categories described above. Since each case is different, it is up to us to craft a convincing argument as to why a particular case should fall in the second category as opposed to the first. The success of such a motion can greatly alter the trajectory of a criminal case, and not only reduce the top count maximum exposure by 9 months in jail (from a class “A” to a class “B” misdemeanor) but also convince a prosecutor to make a more favorable plea offer or even dismiss the criminal charges entirely.

If you have been accused of committing the crime of assault in any degree, it is imperative you consult with an experienced lawyer immediately. The stakes are high in these cases and prosecutors take them very seriously. They carry the potential for jail as well as a permanent criminal record if not properly defended. Attacking the sufficiency of the charges is one of several strategies our team of former prosecutors employs when fighting for our clients, so don’t hesitate to reach out to us if you find yourself accused of this crime.

Client Reviews

I found myself in such a dark place thinking only God could understand and help me through this horrible situation. But Matthew Galluzzo did. And he did so in a very kind, compassionate and respectful manner. Enough said.


Matthew Galluzzo saved the day when the unthinkable happened. Every phone call was returned within minutes. All email correspondences were replied to expeditiously. Matt handled our case as if it was a member of his own family in the courtroom. Despite all the obstacles along the way, Matt's legal...


In less than an hour of assessing my case, Mr. Galluzzo had a clear direction and evoked a confident demeanor that was infectious. During the course of several court appearances he was always prepared, and took more than a personal interest when errors in court procedure occurred. Mr. Galluzzo...


We hired Matt when my son was arrested on several very serious felony charges. Matt is not only very knowledgeable about the law, he genuinely cares about his clients. He was patient and professional, inside the courtroom and out, in what turned out to be a very long process. He worked closely with...


Get in Touch

  1. 1 Over 20 Years of Experience
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 We Fight for You!
Fill out the contact form or call us at (212) 344-5180 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message